A federal judge has ruled that attempts by Elon Musk and the DOGE team to shut down USAID likely violate the U.S. Constitution. This decision follows a lawsuit by current and former USAID employees.
What is the lawsuit about?
In their lawsuit filed on February 13, the plaintiffs argued that Musk unlawfully assumed control as a U.S. official without proper appointment. The Constitution mandates that such officers be appointed by the President and confirmed by the Senate.
Judicial statement and response
Judge, appointed by Barack Obama, concurred that Musk and the DOGE team's actions breach the Constitution. The court partially ruled against mass firings but allowed the cessation of contracts, affecting USAID's global aid operations.
Trump administration's reaction
Donald Trump, with Musk and DOGE, plans to appeal the court's decision. Following his return to office, Trump froze U.S. aid for 90 days and intends to challenge the ruling, labeling some judicial actions as rogue.
The court's decision marks a significant step in defending government agencies against illicit closures. However, the final resolution remains to be seen as the Trump administration prepares an appeal.
