Offering Value Without Creating a Debt

Offering Value Without Creating a Debt

user avatar

by me1afon

31 minutes ago


AI tools helped gather research and write the first draft of this article. I edited it and checked every study figure against the paper or its official abstract, listed at the end. The cover illustration is AI-generated. Details at the end.

In December 2001, a children's charity in Zurich sent 9,846 letters asking for money to fund schools for street children in Dhaka. A third of the letters contained nothing extra. A third contained one postcard drawn by a child. A third contained four [1].

The letters were otherwise identical, and the households were assigned at random. Among people who got no postcard, 12% donated. With one postcard, 14% did. With four postcards, 21% did, an increase of 75% in the number of donors [1].

Nobody had to pay for the postcards. The letter said they were a gift that could be kept or given away. That is exactly why they worked. A gift, even a small one nobody asked for, makes many people feel they owe something back. That feeling is useful and often decent. It is also one of the easiest levers in persuasion to pull without the other person noticing.

This is the second part of Influence & Incentives, a series on how other people, rules and rewards shape what we decide, write and publish. Part one was about social proof. This part is about reciprocity: what the research says about gifts, when a gift turns into a debt, and how to offer something of value without attaching a string to it.

What reciprocity is

Reciprocity is one of the principles of influence that the psychologist Robert Cialdini popularised: when someone does us a favour, we feel an obligation to return it. Most cultures teach it early. It keeps neighbours, colleagues and communities working, because people who give first can expect not to be exploited.

The same norm creates a weakness. The obligation is triggered by the gift, not by whether we wanted it or whether the return is fair. A person who gives first gets to choose both the size of the gift and the moment of the request.

Many claims about reciprocity rest on small laboratory studies from decades ago. The research below was chosen because it measures real behaviour outside a laboratory, or because it covers large numbers of people.

The postcard experiment, read closely

The study is by the economist Armin Falk, published in Econometrica in 2007 [1]. Three details in the full paper matter more than the headline.

The gift was cheap. The postcards cost roughly 2,000 Swiss francs in total, a sum the paper says was covered by the University of Zurich [1]. The author estimates, while warning that the figures are hypothetical, that including them raised net revenue by about 22% compared with sending no gifts at all [1].

The obligation seemed to pull in smaller donations. In the four-postcard group, small donations were somewhat more common than in the no-gift group, and the difference in the distribution was statistically significant [1]. The author's reading is that "feelings of obligation may in fact crowd in relatively low gifts": some people may have given just enough to settle the account, though the differences were small [1].

The effect did not reverse later. The charity's next mailing, in February 2002, went to the same addresses without gifts. Donation rates were 9.6%, 8.9% and 8.6% for people who had been in the no-gift, small-gift and large-gift groups: slightly lower, but differences the paper reports as small and not significant [1]. The extra Christmas donations were not simply borrowed from the next appeal.

A gift does not always pay

Reciprocity is real, but it is not a machine. Francisco Alpízar, Fredrik Carlsson and Olof Johansson-Stenman ran a field experiment with visitors to a national park in Costa Rica who were asked for a voluntary contribution [2]. Some received a small gift before the request.

The gift made people more likely to contribute anything at all. But those who did contribute gave less on average. The total effect was positive but small, and once the cost of the gifts was counted, the authors describe the strategy as "far from profitable" [2]. They also note that the effects they found in the field were smaller than laboratory studies would suggest [2].

So a gift can raise the number of people who respond while lowering what each of them gives. It can make people feel they should do something, and then settle for the least that discharges the feeling. For anyone tempted to use gifts as a growth tactic, that is a useful warning: the obligation is real, but it is shallow.

Small gifts in professional judgement

The cases above involve charity, where the request is open and the cause is good. The more troubling evidence comes from settings where the gift is meant to influence a professional decision that affects someone else.

Researchers led by Colette DeJong matched records of payments made in late 2013 from drug companies to doctors with the same doctors' prescriptions for Medicare patients [3]. The study covered 279,669 physicians and 63,524 payments for four promoted brand-name drugs. About 95% of the payments were meals, with an average value under $20 [3].

Doctors who received a single sponsored meal had higher odds of prescribing the promoted drug instead of others in the same class. The odds ratios ranged from 1.18 for one cholesterol drug to 2.18 for one antidepressant [3]. More meals, and meals costing more than $20, were associated with higher rates of prescribing the promoted drug [3].

This is a cross-sectional study, and the authors are clear that it shows an association, not proof that the meals caused the prescriptions [3]. Doctors who already liked a drug might be more willing to attend a lunch about it. But the pattern is hard to ignore: a gift worth less than a taxi ride is linked to a professional choice whose cost falls on someone else.

When the gift is hidden, it becomes a deception

The step from gift to debt is short. The step from debt to deception is shorter: it happens when the audience cannot see the gift at all.

Regulators treat this plainly. The US Federal Trade Commission's guide for social media influencers says that free or discounted products count as a "material connection" to a brand, and that a creator should disclose the relationship if they got anything of value to mention a product, even if they were not asked to mention it [4]. The disclosure has to be hard to miss, using clear words such as "ad" or "sponsored" [4].

Crypto has its best-known example. In October 2022 the US Securities and Exchange Commission announced that Kim Kardashian had settled charges over an Instagram post promoting EMAX tokens offered by EthereumMax. She had been paid $250,000 for the post and did not disclose it [5]. She agreed to pay about $1.26 million in penalties, disgorgement and interest, and not to promote crypto asset securities for three years, without admitting or denying the SEC's findings [5]. The SEC chair at the time, Gary Gensler, said the law requires promoters to disclose when and how much they are paid to promote investing in securities [5].

The followers who saw that post were not the ones who received the payment. They were the people the payment was meant to reach. When a reader cannot see that the messenger was paid, the messenger's enthusiasm looks like independent judgement.

Airdrops: free tokens do not buy loyalty

Crypto projects run the largest experiment with gifts on the internet: airdrops, where tokens are distributed for free to wallets that meet certain conditions. The hope is usually reciprocity at scale: give users something, and they will stay, use the product and support the project.

Johnnatan Messias, Aviv Yaish and Benjamin Livshits studied nine major airdrops on Ethereum and Layer-2 networks [6]. Their paper, a preprint that has not yet been peer-reviewed, finds that in some airdrops up to 66% of the distributed tokens were sold quickly, often in the recipient's first transaction after claiming [6]. The authors attribute much of this to "airdrop farmers", users who meet the eligibility rules in order to collect and sell. In a case study of the Arbitrum airdrop, short spikes of activity did not turn into lasting engagement [6].

One plausible reading, which these studies do not test directly: a gift creates a sense of obligation when it feels like a gift — unexpected, personal, given without a condition. An airdrop that people expect, with eligibility rules that can be gamed, works more like a payment for meeting those rules. Users treat it like one. A project that designs a gift as a transaction should not be surprised when recipients behave like counterparties rather than like friends.

Three ways a gift becomes a debt

Putting the research together, a gift stops being simple value and becomes a debt in three situations:

  1. The request follows the gift closely, and was the point all along. In Zurich the postcards came with the appeal in the same envelope [1]. That is fine when the cause is open, as it was there. It is a problem when the gift is presented as free and the request appears only after the recipient feels obliged.
  2. The gift is invisible to the people it affects. A sponsored meal or a paid post affects patients and followers who never saw the payment [3], [5]. The FTC's rule of thumb exists because the audience cannot correct for what it cannot see [4].
  3. The gift is sized to the obligation, not to the value. A larger gift produced more donors in Zurich [1]. A free report, tool or token can be calibrated in the same way: generous enough to make refusing the follow-up feel rude.

Five questions before you accept something free

  1. What exactly is being asked in return? Is there a request in the same message, the same thread or the next email?
  2. Would you have chosen this gift? Unrequested gifts trigger the obligation hardest, because you had no chance to decline.
  3. Who paid for it, and does the person recommending it say so? "Free" access, a free token or a free trip given to a reviewer is a material connection.
  4. Does the return match the value? A free checklist is not a reason to connect a wallet, share a private key or sign a transaction you have not read.
  5. What would you decide if the gift had not arrived? Set it aside and judge the request on its own merits.

A worked example (fictional)

The project and all figures below are invented to show the questions in use.

A new protocol posts: "Free 40-page guide to the next cycle, written by our research team. Get it now." The download page asks for an email address. Two days later the email arrives with the guide and a second line: "As a reader of our research, you are eligible for early access. Connect your wallet before Friday."

Run the questions. The request was there from the start; the guide was the first step of a sign-up funnel. Nobody chose this gift; it was sized to look generous. The "research team" works for the protocol, and the guide does not say whether the authors hold its token. Connecting a wallet in return for a PDF is not a fair exchange. And if the guide had never arrived, a message saying "connect your wallet before Friday to a protocol you have not checked" would be easy to ignore.

None of this proves the protocol is dishonest. It shows that the feeling of owing something is doing work that the evidence should be doing.

How to offer value without creating a debt

The research does not say that giving is manipulative. The postcard letter told people what the money was for, and the charity did good work with it. The problem is a hidden condition, not the gift. For anyone who publishes, including this site:

  • Give without a gate. If a guide is useful, publish it. Do not require a repost, a follow or a wallet connection to read it.
  • Keep the gift and the ask apart. If you also want something, a subscription or a purchase, ask for it openly and separately, and make it easy to say no.
  • Disclose what you received. Free products, paid trips, tokens and paid placements go next to the claim, in plain words, every time [4], [5].
  • Do not count on obligation. If people return because the value was real, the relationship lasts. If they return because they felt they owed you, the Costa Rica and airdrop results suggest that obligation buys a small, cheap response rather than a lasting one [2], [6].

What this article cannot tell you

The field experiments here took place in specific settings: one charity's mailing list in Zurich, one national park in Costa Rica. Their numbers do not transfer directly to newsletters, X threads or token launches. The study of sponsored meals shows an association, not cause and effect, and covers five months of 2013 US payment data. The airdrop research is a preprint and covers nine large airdrops; smaller or differently designed airdrops may behave differently. No study here measures how readers of Dapp.Expert or crypto media respond to free offers; that has not been tested. And this is not legal or investment advice; the FTC and SEC material is described only as an example of how regulators treat undisclosed gifts and payments.

How this article was made

Task What the AI did What a person did How it was checked
Research Collected studies on influence and online behaviour into research notes Chose the question and the studies to rely on Figures checked against the papers or their official abstracts [1]–[6]; two studies in the notes were left out because their details could not be confirmed from a primary page
Draft Wrote the first draft from the notes Edited the text, the structure and the worked example A separate review compared figures and claims with the sources
Images Generated the cover photograph-style illustration Chose the illustration; designed the explanatory diagrams Labelled as AI-generated in the disclosure line and alt text
Not done by AI — The decision to publish and responsibility for the text —

Conflicts of interest: none. The author has no commercial relationship with the researchers, companies or organisations named; the protocol in the example is fictional.

Responsible for this article: Dmitriy Lastovka, author. Corrections: contact form.

Sources

Labels: paper (peer-reviewed study, read in full or via its official abstract), preprint (not yet peer-reviewed), official (regulator's own page).

  1. Armin Falk, "Gift Exchange in the Field", Econometrica 75(5) (2007), 1501–1511. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-0262.2007.00800.x Figures from the full text of the working-paper version, IZA Discussion Paper No. 1148, "Charitable Giving as a Gift Exchange: Evidence from a Field Experiment". https://docs.iza.org/dp1148.pdf Paper.
  2. Francisco Alpízar, Fredrik Carlsson, Olof Johansson-Stenman, "Anonymity, reciprocity, and conformity: Evidence from voluntary contributions to a national park in Costa Rica", Journal of Public Economics 92(5–6) (2008), 1047–1060. https://ideas.repec.org/a/eee/pubeco/v92y2008i5-6p1047-1060.html Paper, official abstract.
  3. C. DeJong, T. Aguilar, C.-W. Tseng, G. A. Lin, W. J. Boscardin, R. A. Dudley, "Pharmaceutical Industry-Sponsored Meals and Physician Prescribing Patterns for Medicare Beneficiaries", JAMA Internal Medicine 176(8) (2016), 1114–1122. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamainternmed.2016.2765 Paper, official abstract.
  4. US Federal Trade Commission, "Disclosures 101 for Social Media Influencers". https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/disclosures-101-social-media-influencers Official.
  5. US Securities and Exchange Commission, "SEC Charges Kim Kardashian for Unlawfully Touting Crypto Security" (3 October 2022). https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2022-183 Official.
  6. Johnnatan Messias, Aviv Yaish, Benjamin Livshits, "Airdrops: Giving Money Away Is Harder Than It Seems", arXiv:2312.02752 (version 4, July 2025). https://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02752 Preprint, official abstract.

Tier I

Sector: #18291

Sealed Hiding Place Room

Resource Cache

Resource Cache

Tier I

Requires 25% Tier Progress to Claim
Meme Cache

Meme Cache

Tier I

Requires 50% Tier Progress to Claim
Equipment Cache

Equipment Cache

Tier I

Requires 75% Tier Progress to Claim

After collecting, hiding places will be stored in your inventory and can be opened with Keys.

Other articles

When Social Proof Makes a Bad Decision Easier

Following others is often a sensible shortcut. Research on conformity, online ratings and crypto manipulation shows when it misleads. Five questions to ask.

user avatarme1afon

What Makes a Study of Writing Style Credible?

Seven questions to ask of any style analysis, tested on our own three-writer study: corpus, baseline, coders, agreement, definitions, quotes and grade.

user avatarme1afon

How Molly White Connects Criticism to Sources

Molly White's crypto criticism is the most heavily sourced of three writers we studied. How she ties each judgement to a document, plus a checklist.

user avatarme1afon

How Benedict Evans Uses Comparisons to Build an Argument

Benedict Evans compares new technology with old precedents, yet warns that analogies cannot predict. What his comparisons are for, plus a five-question check.

user avatarme1afon

How Ethan Mollick Builds Explanations Around AI Experiments

A close reading of how Wharton professor Ethan Mollick explains AI: result first, limits next, then a practical step. What writers can borrow.

user avatarme1afon

Sentence Rhythm as an Explanatory Tool

Varying sentence length is not decoration: a long sentence can carry a chain of conditions, a short one can mark the conclusion. Measurements and a method.

user avatarme1afon

Important disclaimer: The information presented on the Dapp.Expert portal is intended solely for informational purposes and does not constitute an investment recommendation or a guide to action in the field of cryptocurrencies. The Dapp.Expert team is not responsible for any potential losses or missed profits associated with the use of materials published on the site. Before making investment decisions in cryptocurrencies, we recommend consulting a qualified financial advisor.